57 Comments
Jul 5, 2023Liked by Erin Reed

Thanks for this and for this newsletter.

I'll keep working to help Maine make this list, but we have a ways to go.

Expand full comment

Colorado was not a great place for me and my partner to be trans despite all the legal protections. First of all the rent isn’t affordable for a single person, but if you’re moving with a family or are financially backed by one you should be ok.

The cities are straight up racist, unlike anything I’ve seen before in a city and I grew up in Texas. There is a huge lack of diversity that probably feeds this, but they look at trans POC like they’ve never seen one of us before, even in downtown Denver or Boulder.

Inevitably I had to leave Colorado and am now homeless due to a discriminatory housing act taken against me and my partner. I made six figures as a Naval Architect but was still paycheck to paycheck, and ran out of money to fight it. I was able to change my legal name quite easily while I was there, but the Denver courts also had no issue that my landlord dug up my deadname to use on the eviction anyways. We’re suing through the Colorado Civil Rights Department and expect to prevail in the next 12 months, but until then I’m living in my car in Michigan, where I first started my medical transition.

Expand full comment

Hi! Minneapolis resident and constituent of Andrea Jenkins (she is my council person) here. Andrea Jenkins is indeed a Black trans woman. She is also a sycophantic rubber stamp for all things our neoliberal, renter-hating, cop-loving mayor and other old guard centrist dems love. She is no progressive and she lost the party endorsement (on the first ballot) to a progressive candidate. I knocked doors for Andrea when she ran for her first term. It didn’t take but a few weeks to see her performance in office to know I would never do that again.

Expand full comment

This is very informative, very timely reporting! I am so glad that these states are enacting such good protections. My worry, of course, is that if the GOP scores a governmental trifecta next year - or if there is a hostile SCOTUS ruling anytime - then these state-level protections could be quickly overridden and thus invalidated. Awful examples would be health care bans, or erasing legal recognition through Kansas-style gender marker laws. What are the chances of that? Another hypothetical: in that scenario, would any of these states be able/willing to resist the federal anti-trans efforts and still provide protections to trans people? I ask only because normally, federal laws usually override state laws.

Expand full comment

Any thoughts on Oregon. I have been deciding between there and Washington based on geological scenery. I love the Pacific northwest and plan to move somewhere in that region.

Expand full comment

This is potentially a wonderful aid to people who are just trying to survive.

Places like Montana, where I am, have got to be frightening for -well - anyone who is different, but particularly those whose sexuality is not straight.

I admire you for what try to do. It is risky, but you do it.

That is heroic.

Expand full comment

How about Illinois? My fiance and I were thinking about moving there from Ohio.

Expand full comment

Another thing about Denver’s cost of living: I was priced out of housing on Pride Weekend because the cheapest hotel that wasn’t booked was $895, making me and my partner have to sleep on a random building rooftop in Boulder for Pride.

Expand full comment

Fantastic and much-needed info. This makes me so proud to be from Seattle. And happy to see that DC is a top place, too, being a transplant. Now let's see the courts strike down more anti-trans legislation. LGBTQ+ folks need and deserve broad choices. I appreciate your work!

Expand full comment

I'm so curious to see which way WI ends up swinging in the coming years. As a trans guy who began HRT while on Badgercare at 17 in 2014 or so, it was honestly the easiest thing in the world from like, the healthcare side of things and while I'm sure that's changing and changed since I moved out, I still think about being baby trans in the mid 2010s in a swing state and how much of a nonissue it was for me to start hormones as a minor. I never had a single doctor, NP, psych, therapist, etc... ever suggest that my being trans was a fad or "social contagion" (despite my whole friend group being LGBT+, mostly trans).

Hell– I'm not sure most of my docs really cared about trans people in one way or another (like, very genuinely neutral to the whole concept of transness beyond dealing with my debilitating dysphoria). Having my dysphoria treated like any other "sex disorder" (insofar as I was treated like a cis teenage boy who was struggling w/ low T during puberty) was for sure a little irritating at the time bc I didn't feel my doctors really knew anything about transness, but in hindsight it was a very low key practice that actually allowed me to feel in control of the way my experiences were being understood by my care providers and in general I actually had a lot of control over my transition. Again, I know that the culture has probably shifted in the last 8 years since I left, but I hope some of that general 'benevolent ignorance' has maintained to a degree, not because I expect there to be incredible protections for trans people in the state, but hopefully it'll at least continue to be one of the less actively hostile places to be.

TL;DR: Not planning on moving out of CA in the forseeable future, but thank you for writing this! One day I'd love to see my home state on a list like this in the future (or at least a "Top 15" list), just based on what it was like nearly a decade ago, but ig I'm not holding my breath.

Expand full comment

So you're saying Mississippi didn't make the cut? That's wierd, I've had such a good time down here 😳

Expand full comment

As a Seattle resident, I was thrilled to see WA at the top of the list! However--as awesome as the Sounders are (and I'm glad they had you recently featured at Pride Night!)--I admit it feels remiss to leave out mention of the women's soccer team, OL Reign, who actually have a trans player, Quinn, regularly in their starting eleven. A massive "protect trans kids" banner is displayed at every game, and the team has previously donned "protect trans kids" t-shirts in warm-ups. Players like Jess Fishlock take part in soccer clinics with trans kids and support TRUK! The OL Reign organization as a whole is a staunch supporter of trans rights! :-) GO REIGN!

Expand full comment

Thanks for this! I wonder if you have any resources or any good information (or could do one yourself) for top 5(?) countries to be transgender in too? Only since I'm interested in moving somewhere and it's big priority in consideration for me. If not no big deal! :)

Expand full comment
Jul 6, 2023·edited Jul 6, 2023

How did Connecticut not make this list? Much better affordability than places like CA, great civil rights protections, the first State in the Country to pass a safe harbor law, and a vibrant queer community.

I consider us to be a Top 5. I do see us in the honorable mentions.

Expand full comment

Wondering about your thoughts on MA. Trying to encourage my trans fam to join me here.

Expand full comment

Hi there, thank you so much for your hard work. It’s been so helpful. What about Delaware or Maryland? My family needs to relocate to protect my teen son. I would love to hear your opinion.

Expand full comment