53 Comments
User's avatar
Carrie's avatar

Another day, another fresh new level of hell to uncover.

If you’d like to focus some love towards supporting and uplifting 2 trans Girl Scouts, I’ve got 2 on Erin’s list still trying to reach their cookie goals -

https://digitalcookie.girlscouts.org/scout/steele757911

https://digitalcookie.girlscouts.org/scout/armando152892

Ellen Adele Harper's avatar

Crazy and punative as these bans are. I believe they are all ultimately unenforceable. What, are all women going to be required to carry their birth certificates with them. Mine says I was born female. Or will all women be required to drop trow or lift skirt. In which case, what of those of us who have had bottom surgery?

Emilia Wang's avatar

There are different types of attacks against marginalized communities: direct legislative, economic pressure and exclusion, psychological attack, denial of personhood, and stochastic violence. Legislations like this are based in psychological attack, denial of personhood, and stochastic violence.

They are meant to make trans people in that state feel afraid, secluded, and ashamed by excluding trans people from public facilities. They make trans people lesser than by denying them equal treatment. They are also meant to legitimate stochastic vigilante attacks on trans individuals by normalizing punitive treatments through state sanctions.

That's why Lemkin just came out with a genocide warning for the US on transgender individuals. Laws like this is what it is, plain and simple. The lamentable part is, not many people know about it. Even amongst allies, it's a little known fact about what's happening.

Freddie Baudat's avatar

And do they want trans men using the women’s room? Or maybe they just hope trans men will break the law and risk jail time?

As this accelerates, we can hope (maybe?) that others wake up to the 250 year old truth that rights are being limited by the majority instead of guaranteed by the Bill of Rights. We all know it.

I’m not betting on it. I keep dropping seeds in the comments sections of my Substack subscriptions and restack posts that spell out what’s happening. And tell (some of) my neighbors.

There’s a line in William Stafford’s poem, “A Ritual to Read to Each Other”:

I call it cruel and maybe the root of all cruelty

To know what occurs but not recognize the fact.

I’m new to this community and I’m so grateful to have found you! Thanks to Heather Cox Richardson for citing EITM in her post a few weeks ago.

Fiadh's avatar

"we can always tell"

Jenn C's avatar

Like hell they can.

Talia Perkins's avatar

"The bill, HB 752", is likely to pass, however I hope not.

I recall this is as open a conspiracy against the individual inherent human rights of US citizens as was Jim Crow -- the people engineering, funding, and carrying out the propaganda campaign and enacting the laws and policies against transgender people must face 42 U.S.C. § 1983, 18 U.S.C. § 241, & 18 U.S.C. § 242 prosecution.

It needs to be a Dem party platform plank.

Fran Fried's avatar

How many of these monsters have ever met a fucking transwoman, let alone been harassed by one in the bathroom? Probably the same number. Zero.

You think a potato boycott would be effective?

Yasha's avatar

More insane cruelty from a party that focuses all of its time on hurting vulnerable people and doing absolutely nothing to make anyone's life better.

Tony D's avatar

Like the Nazis these people want a genocide… of transgender people

Ed Luwish's avatar

I’m sure they are only the first group to face MAGA genocide.

Kris Gosdis Moyer's avatar

Well, besides Iranian schoolgirls and Palestinian refugees… oh, and anyone who looks like they might be an immigrant. But yes. This is not where it ends.

Kathleen Yatsko's avatar

Maybe millions of cis people, all over this nation--but especially in the red states--just need to start using whatever bathroom takes our fancy in the moment and hopefully, all those transphobes would get over themselves really quickly. This whole country should move to unisex bathrooms. This is the most non-issue I have ever seen legislators waste their time on. It is simply, and solely, for cruelty. There is no criminal data or legal reasons driving this sordid legislation. Shame on every legislator who has voted on any one of these bills. Let's all work, in our respective states, to ensure they are voted out of office.

Letters From a Trans-American's avatar

Ugh. This is nuts. This makes it safer for me to pee or ppop on the floor outside the restroom than to use the restroom facilities. What a bunch of cowardly ignoramuses. Someday this madness will come to an end. Perhaps when Barron Trump announces that he's trans.

Ed Luwish's avatar

It wouldn’t make any difference. His daughter and son-in-law are Jewish, and he’s still an antisemistic creep.

Evelyn Belle Scott's avatar

"Never thought I'd die fighting side by side with an [Idaho cop]."

JjMc's avatar

This is truly unforgivable. There is no more deserving state than Idaho for my shit and piss.

Chloe Schwenke's avatar

Presumably the good folks of Idaho would then jail such convicted transgender people in the WRONG prison.

Sarah F's avatar

Yep, that's the idea. I would sooner kill myself.

joy Dunne's avatar

please don't even think of that as an alternative. We need you in the fight. you are loved.

Sarah F's avatar

Oh, I think you misunderstood, but I really appreciate your concern. I meant that if I were thrown into a men's prison with a 5-year sentence, I would kill myself, rather than endure 5 years of being raped and abused as someone's prison wife. That said, I picked the third door, which was to leave the country. I'm a newly minted European. Fuck these fascists! I intend to live. ;-)

Glen's avatar

That's the point of the law.

I assume they will make money off of it...

Kaleigh's avatar

The way this bill is wrote would throw a bunch of cis women in prison for 5 years. What about venues that draw a bunch of women and they take over the men’s restrooms. I think of like Taylor Swift concerts. On second thought they would want to throw Swifties in jail because of their political beliefs. Well they “knowingly enter a men’s restroom”. In Taylor Swift”s case she may no longer take her concerts to states with these extreme laws since you can not guarantee the safety of the fans.

Sarah F's avatar

One step closer to the Project 2025 aspiration that we all go to prison.

Mike Gelt's avatar

Idaho’s HB752 crosses a dangerous line — going even further than similar bills pushed in Kansas and Missouri by Republican-controlled legislatures.

This legislation is not just misguided policy; it is reprehensible, immoral, and fundamentally cruel.

It targets vulnerable people for political gain, weaponizes government power against personal freedom, and sends a chilling message about who is considered worthy of dignity and protection under the law.

Let’s be clear: this is absolutely f**king wrong on so many levels. Laws should protect people, not punish them for who they are.

History will not look kindly on those who chose fear and division over humanity and basic rights.

I want to know which perverted police officer is going to determine who is using the wrong bathroom - if that becomes the case I want to see his or her picture posted in the newspaper and on the national news

lets hope the senate in Idaho has more morality

Laura L. Zielke's avatar

What the actual?!?!? This is beyond cruel and unusual punishment.

Diana's avatar

Sad - how easy it is for these ignorants to play with people's lives for political gain. Absurd.