When I was in high school, a female student sued the district, and won, to be able to join the wrestling team (only males at this time). This case is bullshit and ADF are ambulance chasers, at best.
Well, this is taking the facts, as apparent on the replay and the referee's judgement, that no assault occurred, and turning it into a group lynching. This movement can be mis-performed by any gender with the same result, and had a Cis-female wrestler been the one to make the error, no cry of "assault" would be being made, the other wrestler would shake it off. The parents of the Trans-athlete have the right not to have their child "outed", if parents even need come into this discussion. May I suggest if the Cis-gender female student is uncomfortable with contact that can mistakenly happen between herself and an opponent on the mat, that she may be in the wrong sport? Perhaps she could go out for track and field.
This latest filing involving a transgender wrestler is extremely troubling—and the facts need to be made clear.
The allegation of sexual misconduct has been repeatedly used to portray this transgender athlete as having intentionally sexually assaulted another wrestler. But that is not what the subsequent investigation established. Prosecutors declined to bring criminal charges, and the referee who reviewed the video reportedly said the movement appeared to be an attempted wrestling maneuver and that the hand placement was not clearly outside what can occur during a wrestling match.
That distinction matters enormously.
A wrestling maneuver that goes wrong is not automatically a sexual assault. An allegation is not a finding of criminal conduct. Yet this incident continues to be presented in ways that can make it appear that a transgender athlete deliberately committed sexual misconduct.
Even the Ninth Circuit recognized that the lawsuit centers on an allegation involving one student, while the relief being sought would apply much more broadly to transgender athletes generally. The court denied the requested emergency injunction.
So let's stick to the facts.
What did the investigation actually find? What does the video show? What did the referee conclude? Why was no criminal charge filed? And why should the actions alleged in one individual incident be used to justify policies affecting an entire group of transgender students?
Those are legitimate questions.
We should absolutely take any allegation involving a student seriously. But we should also take evidence, due process and the findings of investigators seriously.
What we should NOT do is take an incident where prosecutors declined to bring charges and turn it into ammunition against an entire transgender community.
If this case is going to be argued before the Supreme Court, then the complete facts—not the most inflammatory version of the allegation—need to be on the table.
What we have is another organization and a parent using this incident as a reason to go after the transgender community again.
It really shows how overblown the whole shitstorm about trans women in sports is, that nothingburger cases like this and 'ol Fifth Place Gaines are the best they can scrape up to prove their point.
It also shows how fucking stupid conservative voters are, that they keep falling for such obvious bullshit and giving these culture war grifters power.
The Alliance Defending Freedom wants to make trans kids less free. You just can't make this shit up. Have you ever seen a sub-community more intent on creating pain, prosecuting bigotry, hurling ridiculous (I almost said Trumped-up, BUT I WON'T) allegations or seeking to perform evil?
Yes, I have. If you haven't, I suggest reading some history books about 1930s Germany and Italy. There's nothing original about what ADF are doing here.
AGAIN, the only people involved who are necessarily child abusers are the Gender Critical/Social Conservative ones. Their "gender ideology" which is the only one that really exists, requires it of them.
I've been pushing back against this campaign since it started here in Washington state. Its nothing more than a false allegation being used to promote a hateful agenda by the right.
This is an almost dead horse, and they keep beating it. Slowly, the trans people in sports is losing its traction, and will eventually be a dead topic, but they TRY to keep breathing life into, and now they're doing so by politics tricks and shenanigans.
I would have sworn I posted this yesterday, but I don't see it now so here it is (again?) -
The whole argument is based on the implicit but abundantly clear idea that because the opponent was transgender (and so "male") the contact was sexual. That's what made it assault. So I'd like the mother to be asked if she would have made the same claims, filed the same motions, if the same contact occurred but the opponent was a cis lesbian.
If we could get an answer to that, which we probably can't, this is what I would argue (in the proper legal form and language, of course):
If the answer is no, then it can be held that the motion is based on animus, not on any actual injury or violation of rights.
If the answer is yes, then the relief requested is inappropriate because it is limited to transgender opponents and that limitation again strongly suggests animus.
If yes with the relief requested expanded to include lesbian opponents, such relief is extraordinarily and overly broad and would require invasion of the privacy rights of all female competitors while overriding the parental rights of all the parents involved to protect their own daughters' privacy..
None of which, of course, even if it could be presented that way, would make an effing bit of difference to the ghouls of the Scurrilous Six who are eager to treat transgender rights the same way they treated the Voting Rights Act, which was to slice away piece after piece until what was left was so thin and frail that it could be knocked down entirely - without ever admitting that was the goal all along. So don't be surprised if they agree with the appeal.
When I was in high school, a female student sued the district, and won, to be able to join the wrestling team (only males at this time). This case is bullshit and ADF are ambulance chasers, at best.
I hate them I hate them I hate them.
Fulsome yet succinct!
Gender fascism. No longer "Our Bodies, Ourselves". It's now, your body IS OURS TO CONTROL.
They've been radicalized with their Transgender Eradication Ideology.
Well, this is taking the facts, as apparent on the replay and the referee's judgement, that no assault occurred, and turning it into a group lynching. This movement can be mis-performed by any gender with the same result, and had a Cis-female wrestler been the one to make the error, no cry of "assault" would be being made, the other wrestler would shake it off. The parents of the Trans-athlete have the right not to have their child "outed", if parents even need come into this discussion. May I suggest if the Cis-gender female student is uncomfortable with contact that can mistakenly happen between herself and an opponent on the mat, that she may be in the wrong sport? Perhaps she could go out for track and field.
This is bull crap. I lost in 2004 for New England and state wrestling championships to a female: I never got mad or considered gender. I got pinned
This latest filing involving a transgender wrestler is extremely troubling—and the facts need to be made clear.
The allegation of sexual misconduct has been repeatedly used to portray this transgender athlete as having intentionally sexually assaulted another wrestler. But that is not what the subsequent investigation established. Prosecutors declined to bring criminal charges, and the referee who reviewed the video reportedly said the movement appeared to be an attempted wrestling maneuver and that the hand placement was not clearly outside what can occur during a wrestling match.
That distinction matters enormously.
A wrestling maneuver that goes wrong is not automatically a sexual assault. An allegation is not a finding of criminal conduct. Yet this incident continues to be presented in ways that can make it appear that a transgender athlete deliberately committed sexual misconduct.
Even the Ninth Circuit recognized that the lawsuit centers on an allegation involving one student, while the relief being sought would apply much more broadly to transgender athletes generally. The court denied the requested emergency injunction.
So let's stick to the facts.
What did the investigation actually find? What does the video show? What did the referee conclude? Why was no criminal charge filed? And why should the actions alleged in one individual incident be used to justify policies affecting an entire group of transgender students?
Those are legitimate questions.
We should absolutely take any allegation involving a student seriously. But we should also take evidence, due process and the findings of investigators seriously.
What we should NOT do is take an incident where prosecutors declined to bring charges and turn it into ammunition against an entire transgender community.
If this case is going to be argued before the Supreme Court, then the complete facts—not the most inflammatory version of the allegation—need to be on the table.
What we have is another organization and a parent using this incident as a reason to go after the transgender community again.
This version of SCOTUS doesn’t care about facts if they see the word “transgender” in the filing. Plus its ADF…
It really shows how overblown the whole shitstorm about trans women in sports is, that nothingburger cases like this and 'ol Fifth Place Gaines are the best they can scrape up to prove their point.
It also shows how fucking stupid conservative voters are, that they keep falling for such obvious bullshit and giving these culture war grifters power.
You are correct, but the problem is the ultra conservative Supreme Court who will probable go along with this bullshit
Geez! If these people don't want their fragile little girl to be touched or grabbed, then why did they allow her to join the wrestling team?!
The Alliance Defending Freedom wants to make trans kids less free. You just can't make this shit up. Have you ever seen a sub-community more intent on creating pain, prosecuting bigotry, hurling ridiculous (I almost said Trumped-up, BUT I WON'T) allegations or seeking to perform evil?
Most right-wing names (e.g. organizations and legislation) are deeply ironic. For instance, Patriot Act. Defense of Marriage Act.
Exactly!
Yes, I have. If you haven't, I suggest reading some history books about 1930s Germany and Italy. There's nothing original about what ADF are doing here.
And I hope they (the ADF) lose big time.
AGAIN, the only people involved who are necessarily child abusers are the Gender Critical/Social Conservative ones. Their "gender ideology" which is the only one that really exists, requires it of them.
Thank you for the reporting, Mrs. Reed.
RE this,
https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/trans-couple-brutalized-at-louisiana
I believe these links are relevant.
https://www.change.org/p/drop-charges-against-aurora-rush-and-shae-sanders
https://www.gofundme.com/aignUrl=legal-fee-support-for-shae
They could use the help I'm sure . . . [and we would appreciate an update!]
I've been pushing back against this campaign since it started here in Washington state. Its nothing more than a false allegation being used to promote a hateful agenda by the right.
So how do we go about creating a class action lawsuit against the Alliance Destroying Freedom? Anyone here a lawyer?
So much hate against so few people!!
This is an almost dead horse, and they keep beating it. Slowly, the trans people in sports is losing its traction, and will eventually be a dead topic, but they TRY to keep breathing life into, and now they're doing so by politics tricks and shenanigans.
I would have sworn I posted this yesterday, but I don't see it now so here it is (again?) -
The whole argument is based on the implicit but abundantly clear idea that because the opponent was transgender (and so "male") the contact was sexual. That's what made it assault. So I'd like the mother to be asked if she would have made the same claims, filed the same motions, if the same contact occurred but the opponent was a cis lesbian.
If we could get an answer to that, which we probably can't, this is what I would argue (in the proper legal form and language, of course):
If the answer is no, then it can be held that the motion is based on animus, not on any actual injury or violation of rights.
If the answer is yes, then the relief requested is inappropriate because it is limited to transgender opponents and that limitation again strongly suggests animus.
If yes with the relief requested expanded to include lesbian opponents, such relief is extraordinarily and overly broad and would require invasion of the privacy rights of all female competitors while overriding the parental rights of all the parents involved to protect their own daughters' privacy..
None of which, of course, even if it could be presented that way, would make an effing bit of difference to the ghouls of the Scurrilous Six who are eager to treat transgender rights the same way they treated the Voting Rights Act, which was to slice away piece after piece until what was left was so thin and frail that it could be knocked down entirely - without ever admitting that was the goal all along. So don't be surprised if they agree with the appeal.