18 Comments
User's avatar
Leah Abram's avatar

Maybe I’m naïve, but I’m optimistic both anti-trans propositions will fail. That doesn’t mean we can rest easy, since there’s no rest for the wicked.

Jayna Sheats's avatar

They will continue to pop up like gophers or prairie dogs (two species who are far, far more attractive and cute than their popular image, but Coloradoans tend to hate them...).

Leah Abram's avatar

So basically, whac-a-mole

Jayna Sheats's avatar

That's about it. But I agree with you that Coloradoans will reject this. After all these years and wrestling with the demons of my childhood there I have some very fond feelings for the state. It's a good place! (Especially as long as Dorothy Rupert is still alive)

Leah Abram's avatar

Colorado has Red Rocks, which is the best-sounding auditorium I ever heard (when I went there to see hometown heroes Big Gigantic). In fact, when I heard how good Red Rocks sounded. I thought it sounded as good as my high-end stereo system at home (which I inherited from my father)! You Coloradans are lucky to have Red Rocks as a venue (and this is from a chick who lives near Madison Square Garden (but *extremely* close to the Barclays Center), so that’s saying something!)!

Larry Erickson's avatar

My best wishes to all of Colorado and my hopes you are wise.

"We must all hang together or we will all hang separately." - Ben Franklin (att.)

Joan the Dork's avatar

If trans kids aren't mature enough to know they're trans, then cis kids aren't mature enough to know they're cis, and everyone should be on puberty blockers until they're 18. Can't have anyone's body irreversibly changing before they hit the age of majority!

...or maybe we could just stop letting stupid bigots craft healthcare policy, so that medicine is practiced on a case-by-case basis the way it fucking well ought to be. It would be ever so nice if we could try it that way instead, the next time this benighted country circles the political drain.

Jayna Sheats's avatar

The phrase “biological reproductive system” did catch my eye. It seems that genetic anomalies therein would disqualify people from athletics, if the body police have their say. Only perfect specimens can proceed in their world...

I realized during a long-delayed visit to my alma mater (Colo. State U) that a portion of me is anchored there. It's a red/blue world, and the blue part is the more populous. Last fall I met some students at the CSU Pride Center who had come to that university because CO was safer (by far) than where they came from. I believe they made the right decision. (And they have my book in their library, which is a nice touch! 🙂)

Mike Gelt's avatar

COLORADO RESIDENTS — OPEN YOUR EYES AND READ WHAT PROPOSITION 135 ACTUALLY DOES.

Proposition 135 is not simply some harmless protect the childrenmeasure. It puts politicians and a one-size-fits-all law between families, patients, and their doctors when making highly personal medical decisions.

And here is something voters need to understand: Colorado’s own Blue Book acknowledges that the measure could reach beyond transgender youth and create uncertainty about other sex- or gender-related surgeries because of the way the law is written.

The Colorado Medical Society opposes Proposition 135, arguing that medical decisions should be made in the exam room based on the individual patient—not dictated by politicians. The Colorado Academy of Family Physicians also opposes it.

This is especially disturbing because the medical evidence shows that these surgeries on minors are extremely rare. Colorado’s three largest pediatric surgical providers report that they do not perform gender- or sex-based surgeries on transgender patients under 18.

So ask yourself: Why are politicians trying to legislate a medical procedure that is already extraordinarily uncommon?

Families deserve privacy. Doctors deserve the ability to practice medicine based on their patients' individual circumstances. And children deserve to have their medical needs evaluated individually rather than turned into a political campaign weapon.

COLORADO VOTERS: READ THE MEASURE. ASK QUESTIONS. LOOK AT WHO IS ACTUALLY OPPOSING IT. THEN MAKE YOUR DECISION.

Families and physicians—should be making these intensely personal medical decisions, and not politians - vote NO on Proposition 135.

Sarah F's avatar

“altering biological sex characteristics”

Hmmmm... This language is interesting. We have been told by the right wing that biological sex is immutable and that it is determined by chromosomes, which of course cannot be altered. But here, we see that "biological sex" has "characteristics" that can be "alter[ed]." That suggests that someone who has had HRT and gender confirmation surgery is not quite the same "biological sex" as an intact cisgender person of the same sex assigned at birth. And that suggests that there are more than two biological sexes. I think the right has introduced an inconsistency in their language that could potentially be exploited to unravel some of their anti-trans legislation. It will be interesting to see if this particular turn of phrase is propagated through the legislative MAGAsphere.

Chibigodzilla's avatar

I'm going over my CO ballot and obviously prop 135 is terrible; but prop 134 really gives away the game. Prop 134 carves our an exception for cis women/girls who want to compete against cis men/boys

Joanne's avatar

As a Colorado resident, I can tell you that Prop 135 is being sold by its millionaire backers as "common sense". Signs saying "Save the Children, Vote yes on 135" are cropping up. I'm amazed that saving the children is always such an emotionally valuable argument, but "I'd rather have a living daughter than a dead son" carries no weight. These are the same people that would have you believe that football playing studs are going to magically start playing on girls' volleyball teams, and that we trans folks are merely lying in wait for the opportunity to assault our cis sisters in the ladies room. I'm heartened by medical organizations who stand up to these fabrications, but the average citizen just doesn't know one of us. They can't put a LIVING face to it that would allow them to say "Wait a minute. I know Jo and SHE's not like that, so maybe other trans aren't either". We're 1% of the population. In most instances, we're the ONLY trans in the room. We may very well be THE ONLY trans person that some will ever meet. It's incumbent on each of us to recognize (for our own very survival) that we are each ambassadors. Make a point of engaging with people. Obviously, be very aware of your surroundings and practice sound risk management, but let people see us. Let them see that we're not some ogre; just another citizen doing what other citizens do. If "common sense" proposals such as 135 succeed in Colorado, it will be the camel's nose under the tent, and we can expect more draconian measures in the future.

Ella's avatar

Thanks for the uplifting bit of good news, s.! It's like a breath of fresh Colorado air.

Letters From a Trans-American's avatar

Thanks, S. Baum, for keeping us informed.

Joel W. Crump's avatar

I believe in Colorado. But it's sad they could even try to harm via health care not given.

Talia Perkins's avatar

I am happy to hear it! Thank you or the reporting, Baum.