Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Madison N's avatar

I don't read as much mainstream media as I used to, so maybe I've missed this if it's happened. But I would really love to see the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychological Association, the American Medical Association, the Endocrine Society, or the World Professional Association for Transgender Healt publish full page ads in the New York times, the Washington Post, the LA times, and every other newspaper of note and express their full-throated support for trans care for minors as well as adults.

Expand full comment
Geoffrey Deweese's avatar

Thank you for this detailed analysis. Articles like this are not unbiased to begin with - they have an opinion and look for evidence in support of that opinion. They don't address the primary issue - can someone, including a child, be transgender? In other words, are they willing to believe that a child/teen is in fact transgender? The need to be honest about this upfront.

If they don't believe (or "aren't sure) that a child can be transgender, then their answer will naturally be how to prevent parents and doctors from damaging children who are not transgender, but just "confused," and they look for evidence to support this conclusion.

They should state upfront that they don't believe doctors, parents, and transgender children.

If you start with the reality that a child can be, and in fact is, transgender, then the answer is to support that child and their parents with the best care possible. And as a parent I know what the best decision is for my child because I listened to him, and I worked with the medical professionals to ensure we (he, my wife, and I) were making informed decisions and following accepted protocols. This is the same as any parent making medical decisions for a child.

The difference is that when a parent seeks care for their child with cancer and has to make decisions about the risks of certain treatments, no one disputes that a child can have cancer. Here, they don't believe my son is transgender. Their bias is clear.

Expand full comment
50 more comments...

No posts